I’ve been thinking about floor cleaning lately after stumbling across a rather heated discussion online. A professional floor restoration cleaner was making some pretty bold claims about why we should all ditch our Swiffers and pre-made mop solutions. Their argument? These products are actually making our floors dirtier over time by leaving sticky residues that trap dirt and grime.

The professional was adamant—almost to the point of rudeness—that traditional bucket-and-mop cleaning with just a few drops of dish soap is the only way to go. They shared some pretty convincing before-and-after photos of floors that had been “restored” after years of Swiffer use, and honestly, the difference was striking. The grime buildup looked like something you’d see in a house that hadn’t been cleaned in years, not one that was regularly maintained with what most of us consider proper cleaning tools.