Posts / frugal-living
The Flat White Is Not the Problem
Someone on r/AussieFrugal did the sums on their daily coffee this week. $5.50 a day, about $1,300 a year, roughly $120k over 30 years if it had gone into an index fund instead. They’d seen the maths on an ad in a bathroom, which is a fairly bleak place to be sold a philosophy of life. Then they kept going. Uber Eats, forgotten subscriptions, the 6pm Woolies dash that turns into $55 of snacks. Half a million dollars over three decades, they reckoned. “A bit horrifying to type out.”
I read the thread over breakfast and I’ve been chewing on it since.
I like the post. It’s honest, and the writer isn’t a zealot about it. They keep their Saturday coffee with mates and say so. But the comments are where it got interesting, because the top replies were mostly some version of: slow down, this maths is a bit of a trick.
One person pointed out that any number sounds outrageous over 30 years. Humans are terrible at imagining large numbers over long periods. Another said that if you’re going to compare a habit to your future super balance, you should compare it to the whole balance and not just the bit you’ve decided to feel guilty about. Both fair. The “latte factor” argument has always carried a quiet assumption that the saved money would actually get invested, every week, for three decades, without anyone ever needing a new fridge. I don’t know anyone who lives like that. I’m not sure I’d want to meet them.
Still, the maths isn’t wrong. It’s just aimed at the wrong target.
The comment that stuck with me wasn’t about coffee at all. Someone said willpower at 6pm on a Wednesday is a depleted resource, so stop relying on it. Build the plan so the easy path is the cheap path. Order the groceries for delivery or click and collect so you never walk past the snacks. Keep one stupidly easy freezer meal on hand. Someone else said they have a rotation of frozen dumplings and flatbreads with fridge leftovers, which beats takeaway on convenience once you’ve got the habit. That’s not frugality as virtue. It’s systems design.
I spend my working life on this sort of thing. Nobody fixes a flaky deployment by telling the engineers to try harder. You remove the manual step that keeps going wrong. The $55 Woolies run isn’t a character flaw, it’s a bad default. Tired and hungry at the end of the day, with a supermarket on the route home, is a system that produces snacks. Change the system.
The coffee, though. This is where I’ll disagree with the maths a bit. I make batch brew at home most mornings, because I work from home most days and a $5.50 coffee on a Tuesday would be absurd. Good beans work out at maybe $1.20 a cup, as one commenter calculated, and a decent machine pays for itself well inside a year. That’s a real saving and I don’t miss anything. But on office days I buy a flat white from the place near the station, and I’ll keep doing it. It’s the one bit of the day where someone else makes something well and hands it to me. I’m not going to put a 30-year compounding rate on that.
There’s a tension here that I don’t think resolves neatly. I like a bargain, and I’m a bit proud of how few things I pay full price for. But a budget that leaves no room for small pleasures gets abandoned in about six weeks. Several people in the thread said as much: rice and beans for every meal would work on paper and fail in a fortnight. The goal is to stop spending on things you don’t even notice. The forgotten streaming trial. The servo drink because you didn’t bring water. Money that vanishes without leaving a memory.
That’s the test I’d use, and it’s not a clever one. Do I remember enjoying it? If yes, it stays. If I have to check the bank app to find out what it was, it goes.
The thread also had a quieter point sitting under it. A lot of this is about being tired. Uber Eats at $35 a go is partly a tax on exhaustion, and plenty of people are exhausted because rent and work and kids take everything they’ve got by the evening. Telling them to cook a Sunday batch is good advice. It also assumes a Sunday with spare hours in it. I have those, mostly. Not everyone does.
So I’ll cancel the one subscription I forgot I had. I’ll keep the flat white on office days. And I’ll make a big pot of something on Sunday, because Wednesday me is a different and weaker man.