Posts / personal-finance
Pre-Tax Money Is Still Money
Someone on r/AusFinance posted about their sister yesterday. She’d landed her first properly paid job, about $95k plus super. Within weeks she’d put a $55,000 RAV4 hybrid on a novated lease. She rents. She has no savings. Her current car is seven years old and runs fine. When challenged, she said, “But it’s pre-tax.”
The thread did what these threads do. A lot of people called her stupid, and a few made RAV5 jokes. I get the impulse, but I don’t think stupid is the right word. I think she got sold something, and it’s very good at selling itself.
The most useful comments came from people who work near these products. A broker said novated leases seem to make people stupid. A payroll worker said the lease companies are a nightmare to deal with. Someone ran the numbers for a mate, found the lease would cost nearly double a plain car loan with a modest deposit, and watched him sign anyway after a phone call with the salesperson. Another person said they’d been fleeced on their first and only one. The word that came up was marketing. The quote puts the benefits in big type: servicing, rego, fuel, tax savings. The interest rate sits off to the side, if it appears at all.
That matches my experience. Years ago, a colleague of mine was pitched one at an office lunch-and-learn. There were pastries, and a nice person with a tablet. Nobody at that table was dumb. But the pitch was built to make the monthly number feel small and the total feel invisible. I do this for a living in a different form: I know how a good interface hides the awkward part. A lease quote is a well-designed interface.
Here’s what I keep coming back to, though. The tax benefit is real. For an EV, with the fringe benefits tax exemption, the numbers can genuinely work. One commenter said their total spend over the lease, balloon included, came in under the drive-away price. I believe them. So the story isn’t “novated leases are a scam”. It’s that a product which suits some people well gets sold hardest to the people it suits least. Someone on $95k, renting, with nothing in the bank and a perfectly good car, is not the target customer the tax rules had in mind. She’s the target customer the sales team had in mind.
I did a smaller version of this myself in my twenties. I got a first decent salary and bought a car I didn’t need, and I told myself a story about reliability. I paid for that story for years. There’s no great wisdom in it. It felt like I’d finally arrived, and the car was a receipt for that. Another commenter described nearly buying a Tesla after jumping from $60k to $112k, then keeping the five-year-old Mazda and booking a month-long holiday instead. That’s the version I admire, and I’m not sure I’d have managed it at their age.
There’s a harder point under all this. Several people said earlier generations were just as silly with money and still bought houses. They have a point. The cost of being wrong used to be a bad car. Now it can be the gap between a deposit and no deposit, and the margin for error is thinner. A 28-year-old with no savings in a rental market like this one has very little cushion, and the stakes of lifestyle creep are higher than they were for her parents. I hold that view alongside the other one, that it’s still her decision and a $55k car is a choice. Both are true. I don’t have a tidy way to reconcile them.
What I’d actually like is for the quote to be required to show the total cost, the interest rate and the end-of-lease position in the same size type as the monthly figure. That’s boring, and it’s the sort of regulation that works. It would also not stop everyone. Some people want the new car and will pay for it, and that’s allowed.
I hope the sister is fine. I hope the RAV4 is a good car and the lease gets paid off without drama. If she wants to save the situation, the first step is cheap: ask for the full cost in writing and read the number at the bottom. It’s the one the salesperson will talk about last.